Beyond Reality - American Idol Recap 4/29/08 Last time Carly Smithson was eliminated. Randy, Paula & Simon. Each finalist sings two songs from the Neil Diamond body of work. Jason Castro - Forever in Blue Jeans & September Morn David Cook - I'm Alive & All I Really Need is You Brook White - I'm a Believer & Iam, I Said David Archuleta - Sweet Caroline & America Syesha Mercado - Hello Again & I Thank the Lord for the Nightime. Paula - are you scripted or what? Tomorrow - someone is going home