Margo meets with Lily and reveals that after tracing Craigs credit cards, she thinks that he really might be in trouble. At the cottage, Mike and Katie share an awkward reunion. Assuming that Mike and Jennifer are sleeping together, Katie decides to let Mike think shes still with Simon. She leaves and goes to vent to Margo, who reveals her concerns about Craig. Meanwhile, Mike assures Jennifer that he has moved on. Lucy and Dusty face off as she calls him on still wearing the necklace she gave him. She tells him to take it off if it means nothing to him but when he does, Lucy is devastated. She declares that its over and leaves. Meanwhile, Rafi goes to the gym, unaware that Dom is setting him up. Dom leaves his jacket for Rafi to find and when Rafi begins ruffling through it, looking for anything to help confirm Dom is behind Craigs kidnapping, Doms suspicions are confirmed. Later, Rafi consoles a miserable Lucy. Meanwhile, Lily continues to look for answers about Craigs disappearance. She goes to Dusty and reiterates that both she and Margo think Craig has met with foul play. Dusty then vows to find Craig in order to protect Lucy. Aaron moves his leg and Alison encourages him. Alison gives Aaron a sponge bath and they grow closer. Jordan and Sierra run into each other while Sierra wrestles with a Christmas. Jordan lends a helping hand and they end up decorating it together. After, Sierra expresses her hope that they run into one another again soon.