After dating for two years, this Chicago couple is ready to buy their first home. They agree they need a backyard big enough to entertain all their friends, including the members of their five different softball teams! However, that's where their agreement ends. Jenny is open to a fixer-upper, while Steve's afraid renovations could bust their $250,000 budget. Jenny likes split-level homes, while Steve's a fan of Colonials. Jenny wants a pool, while Steve bemoans the extra work. But these two have an even bigger decision to make ? when Steve ambushes Jenny with a surprise proposal!