Hal performs a re-enactment of the boathouse explosion. He claims that Craig would never have had the time to set the bomb. When Jack becomes frustrated by Hals about-face on Craig Montgomerys innocence, Hal accuses him of being too emotionally involved with bringing Craig down because of his feelings about Craigs involvement with Carly. Hal decides to confront Craig. Meanwhile, Craig questions Emily about her new alliance with Hal. She continues to take pictures of Craig behind bars until Margo kicks her out. Margo asks Craig to give her one reason to believe that he is innocent. Craig is upset that Margo could even consider that he is responsible for the explosion at the boathouse. Hal arrives and asks Craig to explain exactly how he planted the bomb. Lily dials the number she found on the caller ID and hears Damians voice on the phone. She demands to know where Holden and Luke are but Damian hangs up. Lily is now completely convinced that they are alive. She calls the Chicago police department and they agree to send a detective to check it out. Lily is so grateful for all of Simons help. Detective Adamski is not impressed with the "evidence" that Lily has gathered, but he agrees to look into it. Simon believes that Lily is on her way to finding Holden and Luke. He approaches Rose about collecting the money she offered so he can go rescue Katie. On the island, a bird swoops down and steals the diamond from Katie. Katie is distraught and feels like giving up. Henry frees Cooley from the sand and goes to hunt for food while Cooley tries to comfort Katie. She starts to accept the fact that, although she still dreams of being rescued by Simon, he is not coming for her. Henry finds a bunny rabbit on the island and he plans to cook it, but Katie wants to keep it as a pet.