Now at Ohio State University, Aaron, Alison and Lucy realize that they need to raise money. Alison passes her hat around looking for spare change. Lucy hates the idea of begging and decides to auction off her jacket instead. Before The Oakdale Three leave OSU, Lucy and Aaron take part in the local urban legend to ensure their eternal love. Meanwhile, Hal gets a tip from the local law and he and Craig head to OSU. Craig spots a girl in Lucys jacket but is upset when its not his daughter. Molly and Mike stop by to give Jack and Carly the top of their wedding cake. Jack is called away to deal with James and Molly heads out to run some errands, leaving Mike and Carly alone. Carly admits how worried she is that Rosanna will discover that she and Mike spent the night together. At the Lakeview, Rosanna demands that Henry get the fingerprints off the champagne glasses. Rosanna informs Molly Carly spent the night before her wedding with someone other than Jack. Molly defends Carly, but runs home to tell Carly about Rosannas theories. In jail, Paul asks Barbara to help him put James away forever. James turns himself in and Jack arrests him. When he is placed in a cell next to Paul, James reveals that he and Barbara are married and therefore she wont testify against him. In the station, Jessica confronts Marshall, who admits that he works for James, but insists that he does love her. A furious Jessica offers to represent Paul in court against Marshall.