Hal urges Barbara to accept Rosannas help. Emily sees them share a hug and tells Hal that she longs to share that history with him. Alison arrives and asks Alison for money to go shopping. Emily agrees and she and Hal discuss how nice it is to have a family. She declares that she wants to make it official and asks him to marry her. Holden and Rosanna witness Craig and Carlys kiss. Carly insists that she is not interested in Craig and Holden promises her that he wont tell Jack about the kiss. Rosanna warns Craig to stay away from Carly and storms out. Holden threatens Craig not to talk to Aaron again or hell have to contend with Holden. The men argue and Holden defends Aaron. Carly goes to see Jack and confesses that Craig kissed her. Furious, Jack leaves Carly, finds Craig at Java and beats him up. Jack returns to Carly, but is clearly still upset with her. Meanwhile, Barbara goes to see Rosanna about needing her help with BRO, but she finds Rosanna packing to leave town. She tells Barbara that the offer is no longer on the table and admits that it was all a ploy to get back at Carly. Barbara reads between the lines and asks Rosanna about her feelings for Craig. Barbara advises her to dump him. Rosanna will consider what Barbara has suggested. Later, a battered Craig asks Rosanna for help. Lucy and Aaron kiss in the barn. Aaron gives her the gift from Alison and Lucy realizes that Alison is trying to buy back her friendship. Lucy admits that shell give Alison another chance eventually. Holden informs Aaron that he spoke with Craig, but Aaron still has to earn Craigs trust.